Susquehanna Community School District is upping its game-not merely to save money, though that is important-but to access the multiple advantages afforded by specialization of services and division of labor. The District's schools exist first and foremost, of course, to educate students. In the quest to achieve that goal the District utilizes the best teaching staff it can recruit. Every other service, though perhaps mandated, is secondary or tertiary to the main mission. Among them are food services, transportation, substitute staffing, EMT services, and tax collection.
Reviewing these aforementioned subsidiary services were President Steven Stanford, and Directors Lori Canfield, Amanda Cook, Evelyn Cottrell, Ashley Depew, Carol Jackson, Jamie Koziol, and Martha Stanford at the SCSD work session and regular meeting on Tuesday, March 21, 2017. The work session and regular meeting were conducted back-to-back at 6 p.m. and 7 p.m., respectively. Those meetings were to have been held on Tuesday and Wednesday of the week preceding, but had been postponed due to the days-long blizzard and its aftermath.
In the work session, District Superintendent Bronson Stone briefed board members on 2017-18 budget issues; proposed policy changes; features of the District's 2017-18 calendar; results of the District's transportation data analysis; substitute staffing innovation; food service history and future; EMT contract issues; and tax collection software.
During the District's 30-minute official meeting Directors approved the Memorandum of Understanding (MOU) between the SCSD and Susquehanna County Assessment office for the cost-sharing of tax collector software at the rate of 2/3rd paid by the county and 1/3rd paid by SCSD. Business Manager Gary Kiernan briefly explained the benefits of putting all tax collectors on a uniform system of tax collection. And since he is also Tax Collector for Harmony Township his recommendation carried additional authority, per his familiarity with the system's ease of use. By approving the MOU, SCSD will incur a recurring cost of approximately $1,100 per year.
At the February 2017 meeting Directors approved putting the EMT contract out to bid. The contract provides for an on-site EMT at all home Saber athletic events beginning with the start of the 2017-18 school year. Parties interested in bidding have noted a problematic issue with the proposed wording of one passage in the contract. A clarifying change is to be made. This change will allow contract bidding to go forward in a timely fashion to meet the District's time-line.
SCSD, like most districts in the state, does not own its own buses or vans, and drivers are not school district employees. Mr. Kiernan's analysis of transportation data provided good news for School Directors. His two Comments/Recommendations were these: (1) "No need to bid, spending less than formula OVERALL;" and (2) "Limit how much above formula we pay bus routes before offering to other contractors." Mr. Kiernan is continuing to closely monitor transportation costs, especially in the face of the State's budget environment which may impose a $70,000 reduction in revenue to the District.
School Directors approved granting the Business Office permission to create and advertise a Request For Proposal (RFP) for food service management services. In doing so, the School Board laid the groundwork for outsourcing to a Food Service Management Company (FSMC). The basis for this action is that the District has consistently lost money on food service over the years. Just over the five-year period from July 2011 through June 2016, the District lost $320,000 on food services.
In addition to being a losing proposition financially, the District is concerned about serving meals which students will actually eat. SCHS alumni well remember frizzled beef on the school's menu in the 1960's. It continues to live on in the school's cafeteria 50 years later. Outsourcing to an FSMC may actually end its long run, as well as that of beets and stewed tomatoes. Superintendent Stone noted that current food service workers could remain district employees or work for the FSMC. Mr. Stone clarified also that an RFP, unlike a standard low-bid contract, allows the District to consider quality metrics in awarding any contract. Bringing in an FSMC to provide on-campus meals would, in Mr. Stone's words, "Allow us to concentrate on our primary focus-education-and get us out of the food service business."
Finally, the District has been studying the possibility of outsourcing Substitute Staffing. Kelly Educational Staffing personnel have met with District personnel. Kelly has a proven track record with other school districts in the state, and the firm offers several attractive advantages: a greater substitute pool, lessened administrative burden for the District, and cost effectiveness overall. SCSD's $95 sub actually has an all-in cost of $135.60. Kelly's $95 sub has an all-in cost to the District of $129.58. In the work session Mr. Stone went into depth explaining how Kelly's system operates, as well as how their system would work locally. Moreover, their system guarantees the most qualified substitute available fills any given position, and it virtually eliminates crisis management. Firm action to move forward on outsourcing Substitute Staffing could be forthcoming as soon as next month.
Finally, current budget projections indicate that the District will have a $323,000 hole in the budget for 2017-18. The elementary school's budget will be smaller than the current year, but the high school's will be larger. April's meeting will bring forward a recommendation for how best to patch that deficit hole. A property tax increase recommendation is possible, even likely. District taxpayers may be pleased that at least the District is doing its utmost to turn over subsidiary functions to specialists in the private sector and achieve economies of scale wherever possible.
At meeting's close Mr. Kiernan served up chocolate-drizzled pound cakes baked by students in the high school's Life Skills course. The students responsible for these gastronomic delights are more than deserving of an "A" for their work products. Well done!
April's District meeting is scheduled for the third Wednesday, work session on the preceding Tuesday.
Susquehanna Community School District Board Directors took the following personnel actions during their regular meeting on Tuesday, March 21, 2017.
Approved accepting Intent-to-Retire requests for the end of the 2016-17 school year for the following personnel: Debra Benson – Food Service Manager, and Jeanne Gordon – Kindergarten Teacher.
Approved hiring the following: Alice Rhone – Track & Field Assistant Coach for the 2017 season only; and Melissa Dubas – Varsity Football Cheerleader Advisor for 2017-18 and 2018-19 school years.
Approved the following Volunteer: Jan DeWitt – Varsity Football Cheerleader for the 2017 season.
Approved, pending all appropriate clearances, the following: Christi Albert, Bobbi Madigan, and Chrissy Ayres – K-4 Chaperones; James Paynter – Grade 2 Field Trip Chaperone; Brian Bullick – J.H. Baseball Volunteer for the 2017 season: Judith Herschel – Substitute Teacher.
Approved, pending all appropriate clearances, hiring the following: Matthew Orner – Head J.H. Baseball Coach for the 2017 season; David Cottrell – Assistant J.H. Baseball Coach for the 2017 season; and Robert Goodrich – Track Helper for the 2017 season.
NOTE TO READERS: The phrase “pending all appropriate clearances” is directly linked to state law, effective January 1, 2015, requiring a heightened level of investigative background checks for all volunteers, district employees, and contractors.